Counteracting ambition: Applying corporate compliance and ethics to the separation of powers concerns with domestic surveillance
Loading...
Authors
McGreal, Paul E.
Issue Date
2007
Volume
60
Issue
4
Type
Journal Article
Language
Keywords
Alternative Title
Abstract
When it comes to domestic surveillance, even in the name of foreign intelligence, one constitutional challenge is to balance suspicion of and confidence in executive power - to leave the executive flexibility to meet changing threats, while ensuring that flexibility is not a pretext for abuse. To address this challenge, this Essay draws on expertise from an area of private law: the design, implementation, and operation of corporate compliance and ethics programs. A corporate compliance and ethics program consists of an organization's code of conduct, policies, and procedures that help achieve compliance with relevant laws as well as the organization's ethical standards. My thesis is that constitutional separation of powers analysis ought to incorporate lessons from corporate compliance and ethics programs. Over the last half century, businesses have accumulated vast expertise on checking and balancing the exercise of corporate power to protect shareholder value. The federal government ought to employ similar measures to protect our constitutional values. Corporate compliance and ethics best practices, then, should guide analysis of whether a given exercise of federal power incorporates adequate checks against abuse.
Description
Citation
Paul E. McGreal, Counteracting Ambition: Applying Corporate Compliance and Ethics to the Separation of Powers Concerns with Domestic Surveillance, 60 SMU L. Rev. 1571 (2007).